Tiki Barber’s Unfortunate Anne Frank Comparison.

Oh, brother.

That’s about the nicest and most restrained thing I can say about once and possibly future NFL running back Tiki Barber.

In this week’s Sports Illustrated, he offered up this gem, according to an ESPN article:

At one point in the article, Barber describes going into hiding with his girlfriend after his well-publicized breakup with his then-pregnant wife. Barber and his girlfriend ended up in the attic of the home of the player’s agent, Mark Lepselter.

“Lep’s Jewish,” Barber told Sports Illustrated. “And it was like a reverse Anne Frank thing.”

Let’s see.

Hiding from your pregnant because you left her for an intern is the reversal of a Jewish girl and her family hiding from the Nazis for two years, never knowing that what ultimately did happen-she was betrayed and killed in the Bergen-Belsen camp-would come to pass.

It could just be me, but I don’t get it.

Don’t get me wrong.

We all make mistakes, although the ESPN piece includes a quote from the aforementioned Jewish lawyer to the effect that Barber was a guest of the Israeli government five years ago-the implication there being that thus there is no possible way that anyone could have taken offense to his statement.

Athletes living under the microscope misspeak all the time, as we saw this week with Joakim Noah’s homophobic outburst and Kobe Bryant’s similar epithet several weeks ago.

Athletes aren’t role models (Thanks for that, Charles Barkley, circa early 1990s).

Blah, blah, blah.

At times, I wonder if the trivialization of the Holocaust will ultimately do more to erode its meaning than anything the deniers could ever hope to accomplish.

As readers of this space know, since we’ve started as a community, I’ve written about Obama being compared to Hitler, Arizona’s SB 1070 being compared to Nazi Germany, and a Congressional candidate from Ohio defending his going into the woods dressed as a member of the Waffen SS because they didn’t actually carry out atrocities.

Now this.

An athlete’s unfortunate comparison does not rank up there with, say, the capture today of Ratko Mladic, the Serbian genocide architect, whose actions at Srebenica form another in the long line of human atrocities.

But words do matter, and I do hope that Barber uses his damaged, but still influential persona, in better ways in the future.


3 responses to “Tiki Barber’s Unfortunate Anne Frank Comparison.

  1. Ignorance… Sometimes people take one statement, one action and apply it to something current without thought or conviction. Pure ignorance.


  2. David Russell

    I like your line: “At times, I wonder if the trivialization of the Holocaust will ultimately do more to erode its meaning than anything the deniers could ever hope to accomplish.” The deniers are marginal, and it is an accomplishment that basically everyone is familiar with the term “Holocaust,” but it seems that that familiarity is often accompanied by a casualness of attitude; having heard so many references to the atrocity, attention to its magnitude can be eroded. I agree with you in criticizing Barber, etc. It’s not that you a making a big deal out of a little thing; they are making a little thing out of a big one.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s