Aidan’s Paper, Dave Cullen’s Columbine

Dave Cullen's Columbine was a major source for Aidan's English term paper.

 

I spent about three hours last night working with Aidan on his English Term Paper. 

His topic is a grim one: the deadliest high school and college shootings in American history. 

Aidan’s learned a lot about the Columbine and Virginia Tech killings, and through that process, has decided that mental illness, rather than bullying, was the primary cause that propelled Dylan Klebold, Eric Harris and Seung-Hui Cho to kill more than 40 people before turning the guns on themselves. 

His argument is an effective one. 

Aidan draws on articles, the Virginia Tech report, and cartoons to show that bullying, while a pervasive problem in our nation, was less of a motivating force than Klebold’s suicidal depression, Harris’ psychopathy, and Cho’s mental disorders. 

A major source for Aidan was Dave Cullen’s Columbine, most of which he read during our trip last December and this January to Israel. 

I’ve written before about Cullen, a Dart Fellow who spent a decade and went through at least one publisher before completing the work. 

Cullen’s assertion about the killers’ mental states is just one of the many reasons to read this haunting and richly informative book.  He takes on the controversial issue of Cassie Bernall, a young woman who allegedly answered “Yes” when asked by one of the killers if she still believed in her faith shortly before he killed her. 

The book’s panoptic perspective builds a sense of mounting horror as Klebold and Harris accumulate their cache of weapons, publicize their increasingly detailed plot on Harris’ web site. 

Nearly as chilling, if not more so, is Cullen’s description of the system failures in the school’s handling before, and the law enforcement system’s bungling and deception after, the massacre. 

Another point that Cullen makes, and that Aidan brought out in his paper, is that the death toll could have been exponentially higher had the bombs they designed and made actually detonated as the school as planned. 

Of course, the carnage was horrifying, even for a nation accustomed to seeing thousands of violent acts on television on a weekly basis.  While I was hoping to get to Eleanor Flexner’s Century of Struggle last night, I’m grateful to have so much time to spend with Aidan and to have my memory refreshed about the power of Cullen’s work.

Advertisements

2 responses to “Aidan’s Paper, Dave Cullen’s Columbine

  1. I’ve been urging anyone blogging about Cullen’s “Columbine” to read at least one other book on the subject, and that’s “Comprehending Columbine” by Ralph Larkin. In my opinion it takes a far more accurate look at what happened at Columbine, and why.

    Cullen’s research, again in my opinion, is flawed and faulty, and I’m not the only one to think so. There are amateur researchers out there who seem to be more well informed than Cullen on the subject, and they mostly hold the book “Columbine” in low regard. None more so than Randy Brown, whose son Brooks was a classmate and friend of both Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold. So contemptuous of Cullen’s book is Brown that he all but calls it a “work of fiction”. If you haven’t already read his 1-star review of “Columbine” you can at this link: http://www.amazon.com/review/R3AJEK6T7746K6/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm

    Another well-informed negative review of the book is here: http://www.amazon.com/review/RKT7NOFW8H8OH/ref=cm_cr_rdp_perm

    Again, if your Aidan can stand to read one more book on the subject then I really strongly recommend Larkin’s “Comprehending Columbine”. Larkin spent much more time interviewing past and present students at Columbine High School and he comes to quite a different conclusion than does Cullen regarding bullying as a motivating factor in why the attack occurred.

    • jeffkellylowenstein3

      Thanks, Lisa, for this thoughtful post and helpful links. I will check out Larkin’s book and recommend it to Aidan, too.

      Jeff

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s